Mattress Toppers: warranties compared
3 brands. We read every warranty so you don't have to. Checked through October 2026.
3 of 3 brands cover mattress toppers in full for one year or less. 3 brands keep some parts covered after full coverage ends.
Every brand, side by side
From each maker's published warranty. “Unverified” means we couldn't confirm the terms on the maker's own site. How we rate warranties
What these warranties often leave out
- Normal wear and tear2 of 3 brands
- Stopping working from outside causes1 of 3 brands
- Water damage1 of 3 brands
How long stores give you to return it
Longest return window first, for mattress toppers.
- CostcoMost itemsNo fixed deadline
- Slumberland FurnitureUpper Midwest storesMattresses (365-Night Sleep Guarantee)365 days from delivery
- Mattress FirmMost items120 days from delivery
- Levin FurnitureWestern Pennsylvania and Ohio storesPremium mattresses (Tempur-Pedic, Stearns & Foster, Serta, Sealy, Beautyrest) with protector and pillow120 days from delivery
- Mattress WarehouseMid-Atlantic storesMattresses (Comfort Guarantee exchange, most brands)120 days from delivery
- Nebraska Furniture MartMidwest and Texas storesMattresses120 days
Show all 32 stores
- Raymour & FlaniganNortheast storesMattresses120 days from delivery
- Star FurnitureTexas storesMattresses (Comfort Guarantee)120 days from delivery
- SteinhafelsWisconsin storesMattresses (120-Night Sleep Guarantee)120 days from delivery
- Jordan's FurnitureNew England storesMattresses (Sleep Lab Sweet Dreams Guarantee)100 days from delivery
- RC WilleyMountain West storesMattresses (100-Night Mattress Comfort Guarantee)100 days from delivery
- TargetMost items90 days
- WalmartMost items90 days
- American Furniture WarehouseMountain West storesMattresses90 days from delivery
- Lack's Home FurnishingsTexas storesMattresses (90-Day Comfort Promise)90 days from delivery
- P.C. Richard & SonNortheast storesMattresses90 days from delivery
- BJ's Wholesale ClubMattresses, box springs and bed-in-a-box30 days
- HomeGoodsMost items30 days
- Kohl'sMattresses30 days
- WayfairMattresses30 days from delivery
- Electronic ExpressTennessee storesMost items30 days
- American Signature Furniture (Value City Furniture)Most items7 days from delivery
- CuracaoSouthwest storesFurniture and mattresses7 days
- Furniture Row (Denver Mattress)Special-order mattress sizes (Split King, California King, Twin XL, Full XL), adjustable bases, and used or unpackaged beddingNo returns
- Bernie & Phyl'sNew England storesPillows and mattress protectorsNo returns
- Big Sandy SuperstoreOhio Valley storesMattresses, foundations and bedding accessoriesNo returns
- BrandsMart USASoutheast storesFurniture and mattressesNo returns
- Gardner-WhiteMichigan storesMattresses, bedding, special orders, floor samples and As-Is itemsNo returns
- HavertysSouth storesAdjustable bases, foundations, pillows, sheets, some value mattressesNo returns
- Living SpacesWest storesMattresses, box springs and beddingNo returns
- Mor Furniture for LessWest storesMattresses, bases, bedding, pillows, sheets and mattress protectorsNo returns
- Sit 'n SleepSouthern California storesCloseout and floor sample mattressesNo returns
From each store's published return policy, using its rule for mattress toppers where it has one. Member and holiday extensions aren't counted. Check yours before you buy.
More Home & Furniture warranties
- Mattresses: warranties compared32 brands
- Office Chairs: warranties compared26 brands
- Lighting: warranties compared23 brands
- Furniture: warranties compared22 brands
- Bedding & Pillows: warranties compared20 brands
- Bed Frames & Bases: warranties compared19 brands
- Cabinets & Countertops: warranties compared19 brands
- Desks: warranties compared17 brands
- Sofas & Sectionals: warranties compared15 brands
- Closet & Garage Storage: warranties compared9 brands
- Cribs & Kids Furniture: warranties compared8 brands
- Rugs & Carpet: warranties compared8 brands
Questions shoppers ask
Which brand of mattress toppers has the best warranty?
On paper, Eight Sleep scores highest, with no full coverage but some parts covered to 5 years.
Is a long warranty on mattress toppers really that long?
Often not for the whole product. Many longer warranties cover only certain parts after the first year or two, and you usually pay for the labor. The bars above show full and partial coverage separately.
Do I need to register to get the warranty?
None of the 3 brands require registration for their basic coverage. Registering can still get you recall notices. Keep your receipt either way.
Forward the receipt and I-BUY.AI tracks the return window and warranty for you.